Saturday Great Vespers 5:00 PMSunday Orthros 9:30 AM, Divine Liturgy 10:30 AMWatch live

St. Mary's Antiochian Orthodox ChurchBay Ridge, Brooklyn

About

Our history

St. Mary’s was founded in downtown Brooklyn in 1917 as a cathedral for Orthodox Christians loyal to the ancient Patriarchate of Antioch, and it has been on Ridge Boulevard in Bay Ridge since 1951. In more than a hundred years it has had only five pastors.

Because it has had two homes, the parish keeps two anniversaries. In 2001 it prepared to celebrate fifty years in Bay Ridge, and in 2007 it celebrated ninety years since its founding.

A cathedral for Antioch, 1917

Orthodox Christianity first came to North America with Russian missionaries in Alaska in the 1700s. For many years the Russian Church cared for all the Orthodox immigrants who followed, including the Arabic-speaking Orthodox, who were then called “Syrians”. In the 1890s Archimandrite Raphael Hawaweeny came to America to gather these scattered families into parishes. In 1895 he founded the community that became St. Nicholas Cathedral, and in 1904 he became the first Orthodox bishop of any background to be consecrated in America. The Church glorified him as St. Raphael of Brooklyn in 2000.

St. Raphael died in 1915. After the Russian Revolution, the Arabic-speaking parishes were divided over who should lead them: some looked to the Russian Church, others directly to the Patriarchate of Antioch. Metropolitan Germanos Shehadi of Zahle, who had come from Lebanon to raise funds and could not return because of the First World War, gathered the parishes that wanted to stay with Antioch. On February 3, 1917 he founded a cathedral for them: the Assumption of the Theotokos Cathedral, better known as St. Mary’s. It worshiped in a former synagogue at Boerum Place and State Street in downtown Brooklyn. Metropolitan Germanos’s pastoral staff is still on display at St. Mary’s.

The division lasted almost twenty years. In 1936 Metropolitan Antony Bashir was elected to lead the Archdiocese, the two sides were reconciled, and St. Nicholas Cathedral and St. Mary’s came under the same bishop.

The first pastors

St. Mary’s first full-time pastor was Fr. Seraphim Nassar (1926 to 1928). He compiled Divine Prayers and Services, the large book of services that Antiochian parishes still use. Archimandrite Agapios Golam followed (1928 to 1936). Fr. Abdallah Khouri, who was married to St. Raphael’s niece, served from 1936 to 1955. He carried the parish from its downtown years into Bay Ridge, and served alongside Fr. Paul Schneirla after the new church was built. Fr. Faried Farkouh also helped serve the parish in his later years.

From downtown to Bay Ridge

In the 1940s the City of New York bought the Boerum Place property to build a jail. Metropolitan Antony kept the money from the sale in trust at St. Nicholas Cathedral, along with the parish’s icons, vestments, records and relics.

Meanwhile many young families were moving from downtown Brooklyn to Bay Ridge. Archimandrite Peter Horton-Billard, a convert serving as Metropolitan Antony’s chancellor at the Archdiocese headquarters on 85th Street, saw that their children were being drawn to the English-speaking Protestant churches of the neighborhood. With the Metropolitan’s blessing he opened a small mission above a bakery on 86th Street. He started a choir and helped Shukrie Thabit organize a Church School. When the mission closed, the Church School kept meeting in Mrs. Thabit’s home on 82nd Street, and kept alive the hope of a parish in Bay Ridge. The parish’s own history says that without Fr. Peter there would be no St. Mary’s today.

William Zarick bought the lot at 81st Street and Ridge Boulevard, and Metropolitan Antony appointed a building committee with Anis G. Khouri as chairman. When Mr. Khouri died in 1951, before the church was furnished, Aleer J. Couri succeeded him. Eli N. Khouri, Joseph M. Ashi, Dewey J. Awad, Henry Hadad, Gabriel Howie, Abraham G. Mouracade, Victor M. Samra, Sr., and Najeeb Sydnawey completed the committee. Paul T. Dib and Edward A. Zraick gave early guidance and led the first fund-raising. The first plan was a modest Sunday School building, but as more and more people took an interest it grew into a church. Metropolitan Antony worked tirelessly for it, and added the funds held from the old St. Mary’s to what the parish raised. He laid the cornerstone in February 1951. The parish was incorporated on July 12, 1951, and on October 7, 1951 Metropolitan Antony and Archbishop Samuel David dedicated the new church, assisted by Fr. Abdallah Khouri and Fr. Wakeem Dalack. The newly appointed pastor, Fr. Paul Schneirla, joined the dedication banquet that evening.

Fr. Paul’s half-century

Fr. Paul Schneirla was pastor from the opening of the Bay Ridge church in 1951 until he retired in October 2002: 51 years. Raised Protestant, he was one of the first converts to serve as an Orthodox priest in America, and had served parishes in Iron Mountain, Michigan, and Allentown, Pennsylvania, before coming to St. Mary’s. He was a priest for 71 years.

Fr. Paul was one of Metropolitan Antony’s most trusted advisers. He served as Secretary of the Archdiocese, taught Old Testament at St. Vladimir’s Seminary, was the first editor of The WORD magazine, helped found the Standing Conference of Orthodox Bishops in America, was Vicar General of the Western Rite, and represented the Archdiocese in dialogues with other churches. He taught and guided many seminarians, among them Fr. Michael Ellias. For twenty-five years an assistant priest, a clinical psychologist by training, served beside him, counseling parishioners and helping with the Church School.

Fr. Paul fell asleep in the Lord on September 20, 2014, aged 98. A bronze plaque with his likeness hangs at the church entrance, and in 2021 New York City named our block of 81st Street “Fr. Paul Schneirla Way”. May his memory be eternal!

Parish life in Bay Ridge

The new church soon filled. At the height of the baby boom the Church School had more than 300 students, under the strong hand and firm direction of Alice Hamatie, and some of its children grew up to become priests, or to marry priests.

St. Mary’s young people have long been leaders in the Archdiocese’s youth movement, SOYO, and in Teen SOYO, regionally and nationally, and have done well in the Oratorical Contests, Bible Bowls and Creative Arts Festivals.

The choir sings a blend of Byzantine and Slavic music in English. A baritone of the Metropolitan Opera arranged much of its music, one choir director led it for forty years, and a long-serving chanter compiled the Byzantine Music Project for use across the Archdiocese and beyond.

For generations the Ladies of St. Mary’s have kept the parish’s traditions, raised funds and organized much of its social life.

Today

When Fr. Paul retired in 2002, Metropolitan Philip appointed Fr. Michael Ellias as the fifth pastor of St. Mary’s. Fr. Michael had been a seminarian at St. Mary’s from 1982 to 1984, and married Khouria Laila, a daughter of the parish. Since then the church has been renovated. The parish kept its hundredth year in 2017 with a gala in its newly renovated church hall.

Families descended from the founders still worship at St. Mary’s, alongside people of many backgrounds who have found a home here.

Timeline

  • 1895. Archimandrite Raphael Hawaweeny (St. Raphael of Brooklyn) founds the community that becomes St. Nicholas Cathedral.
  • 1915. St. Raphael dies.
  • February 3, 1917. Metropolitan Germanos Shehadi founds the Assumption of the Theotokos Cathedral, St. Mary’s, at Boerum Place in downtown Brooklyn.
  • 1926 to 1928. Fr. Seraphim Nassar, the first full-time pastor.
  • 1928 to 1936. Archimandrite Agapios Golam, pastor.
  • 1936. Metropolitan Antony Bashir is elected, and the Archdiocese is united.
  • 1936 to 1955. Fr. Abdallah Khouri, pastor.
  • 1940s. The City buys the Boerum Place property. A mission and Church School begin in Bay Ridge.
  • February 1951. Metropolitan Antony lays the cornerstone at 81st Street and Ridge Boulevard.
  • October 7, 1951. The new church is dedicated. Fr. Paul Schneirla becomes pastor.
  • October 2002. Fr. Paul retires after 51 years. Fr. Michael Ellias becomes pastor.
  • 2007. The parish celebrates its 90th anniversary.
  • September 20, 2014. Fr. Paul falls asleep in the Lord, aged 98.
  • 2017. The parish celebrates its centennial with a gala in its newly renovated church hall.
  • October 24, 2021. New York City co-names 81st Street at the church “Fr. Paul Schneirla Way”.

Sources

The Library’s photographs are under copyright, so we link to them rather than show them here.